Season 1
- 1Cal Ripken Jr.16 Jan 2014
- 2John Smoltz23 Jan 2014
- 3Ozzie Smith30 Jan 2014
- 4Bob Gibson30 Jan 2014
- 5Johnny Bench6 Feb 2014
- 6Tom Glavine6 Feb 2014
My Most Memorable Game features Cal Ripken Jr., eight-time All-Star John Smoltz, and Hall of Famers Ozzie Smith, Bob Gibson, Johnny Bench and Tom Glavine as they relive the memories they have from a signature game in their storied careers.